When it comes to high-quality bourbon at an affordable price, few names stand out more than Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare. Both manufactured at the same distillery by the Sazerac Company, these bourbons deliver smooth, rich flavors and exceptional value.
But what really sets these two bourbons apart? Is one better suited for sipping than the other? Which deserves a prime spot in your collection?
This guide explores the differences between Eagle Rare vs Buffalo Trace to help you pick the perfect bottle. From ingredients to taste profiles, we cover everything you need to make a confident choice for your next pour.
Grains
While Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace share almost the same mash bill, they have slightly different grain proportions, which affect their overall taste and flavor profile.
Buffalo Trace
-
Corn: Approximately 90%
-
Rye: Around 8%
-
Malted Barley: Approximately 2%
Eagle Rare
-
Corn: Approximately 80%
-
Rye: Estimated 12%
-
Malted Barley: Roughly 8-10%
Distillation Process
Both bourbons are distilled at Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, Kentucky, owned by the Sazerac Company. In the past, the distillery has operated under several different names, including the Old Fire Copper Distillery and the George T. Stagg Distillery.
For the most part, the distillation process is similar for both bourbons. However, there are subtle alterations that result in differences in taste.
Water source
Both Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare benefit from Kentucky’s naturally limestone-rich water, which contributes essential minerals that help develop a smoother texture and more layered flavor in the final bourbon.
Distillation
The high-quality copper stills used in the production process play a vital role in refining the spirit and removing impurities. However, subtle differences in the production methods set each bourbon apart.
Eagle Rare is typically distilled at a slightly higher proof, which can lead to a bolder, more structured flavor profile. Additionally, the filtration techniques used for each brand differ, influencing everything from the mouthfeel to the overall smoothness of the final pour.
Maturation
Buffalo Trace bourbon is typically aged between eight and nine years, with barrels stored across different areas of the warehouse. This approach introduces subtle variations from batch to batch, giving each bottle its own unique character.
In contrast, Eagle Rare is aged for a full 10 years under more controlled warehouse conditions, allowing for greater consistency and a more uniform flavor profile across each release.
Barrel Selection
Even though both bourbons make use of charred American oak barrels, there are still a few important differences. One of the key distinctions between Buffalo Trace vs Eagle Rare lies in how their barrels are chosen and managed during the aging process.
Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace barrels are pulled from various locations throughout the distillery’s massive warehouse network. This varied barrel placement creates subtle batch-to-batch differences, which adds a layer of uniqueness to each release. While the flavor profile remains consistent overall, small nuances make each bottle a little different, especially for eagle-eyed bourbon fans.
Eagle Rare
Eagle Rare takes a more selective and controlled approach. Barrels are typically stored in specific warehouse zones that offer more stable temperatures and humidity levels, leading to a smoother, more consistent aging process. Only barrels that meet Eagle Rare’s higher standards are selected, often resulting in a more refined and uniform flavor profile across each bottling.
Different Expressions
Whiskey enthusiasts are spoiled for choice when it comes to the different expressions offered by Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare. Let's take a closer look.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Buffalo Trace Bourbon comes in one much-loved expression, available in 750ml or 1-liter bottles. You could also buy the 6-bottle bundle if you want to stock up.
Eagle Rare Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey
Eagle Rare comes in five core expressions, including:
-
Eagle Rare 12 Year Bourbon Whiskey
-
Eagle Rare 17 Year Bourbon Whiskey
-
Eagle Rare 25 Year Bourbon Whiskey
-
Double Eagle Very Rare
These expressions cater to a range of preferences, from accessible to exclusive.
Tasting Notes
From Buffalo Trace, you can expect a smooth and balanced flavor profile with notes of caramel, vanilla, toasted oak, and spice. There are subtle hints of dark fruit and brown sugar on the finish, making it approachable yet flavorful.
Eagle Rare, on the other hand, is richer and more mature, delivering layers of toffee, leather, orange peel, and oak, with a longer, more refined finish. Its 10-year aging brings out deeper complexity while still remaining smooth.
Pricing & Value
Buffalo Trace continues to be one of the best-value bourbons available, typically retailing between $25 and $35. Eagle Rare, with its 10-year age statement, usually sets you back around $40–$60, with more exclusive expressions going for thousands of US Dollars. These bourbons punch well above their price points, offering flavor and quality that rival more expensive bottles.
Branding & Packaging
Buffalo Trace has a rugged look, with an image of the American bison on the label and earthy green tones that echo its Kentucky roots. Clearly inspired by bourbon's rich history in the United States, it's easy to see why this bottle has mass appeal.
Eagle Rare presents a sleeker, more elegant design, with a tall, slender bottle, minimalistic font, and a soaring eagle etched into the glass. This high-end packaging reflects the premium feel of the spirit inside.
Availability
Buffalo Trace is widely distributed and relatively easy to find, although high demand can cause periodic shortages.
Eagle Rare, on the other hand, tends to be more limited in availability and can be tricky to track down depending on your region. This is especially true of the older expressions. When you see them on the shelf, they're worth picking up if you're in the market for something exclusive.
Awards
Both bourbons have received multiple awards over the past decade, further solidifying their popularity and success in the bourbon market.
Buffalo Trace Bourbon Whiskey
-
Double Gold Medal: San Francisco World Spirits Competition
-
Gold Medal: New York International Spirits Competition
-
Frequently named one of the Best Value Bourbons by Whiskey Advocate and other leading publications.
Eagle Rare Bourbon Whiskey
-
Double Gold Medal: San Francisco World Spirits Competition
-
Gold Medal: Los Angeles International Spirits Competition
-
Winner of Best Straight Bourbon at multiple tasting events
-
Consistently earns 90+ ratings from whiskey critics and enthusiasts worldwide.
Best Ways to Enjoy
Buffalo Trace is versatile and shines in classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, or Whiskey Sour. However, it's just as enjoyable neat or with a splash of water, served in a proper whiskey glass to get the most out of this drink.
Eagle Rare, with its richer profile, is best appreciated neat or on the rocks, allowing its complex notes to develop fully with each sip. You don't need to drink a lot to appreciate the complex flavors.
Food Pairings
Pair Buffalo Trace with barbecue, smoked meats, roasted chicken, or even pecan pie. The drink's spicy-sweet flavor complements rich, savory dishes perfectly.
Eagle Rare pairs beautifully with dry-aged steak, dark chocolate, spiced nuts, and aged cheese, making it an excellent choice for a more refined meal or dessert pairing.
Target Market
Buffalo Trace appeals to everyday bourbon drinkers, cocktail lovers, and newcomers looking for quality without a hefty price tag. Eagle Rare targets more seasoned sippers, collectors, and those looking to level up from entry-level pours without breaking the bank.
Gifting Options
Both Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare make fantastic gifts for bourbon enthusiasts. Their award-winning quality, beautiful packaging, and strong reputation make them crowd-pleasers.
If you want to go the extra mile, you could opt for one of the incredible gift sets available, some of which include collectible glasses and bullet ice stone crates, among other items.
FAQs
Which is better, Eagle Rare or Buffalo Trace?
Both options are known for their exceptional craftsmanship, layered flavor profiles, and premium quality. If you're looking for something rich, complex, and exclusive, Eagle Rare may be the right option for you. However, if you'd prefer a bourbon that is accessible and slightly sweeter, Buffalo Trace may be a better choice.
What is the holy grail of bourbon?
Pappy Van Winkle is often referred to as the "holy grail of bourbon". However, there are many other contenders for this top spot, including Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare, and Blanton's Gold. All of these brands have made highly regarded names for themselves within the bourbon industry.
What makes Eagle Rare so popular?
Eagle Rare has gained mass appeal thanks to its layered flavors, affordability, and limited availability. This highly sought-after spirit offers exceptional quality at an affordable price point, making it a popular choice for bourbon drinkers.
What other alcoholic beverages does the Sazerac Company make?
The Sazerac Company has an extensive portfolio of products, including gin, vodka, whiskey, rum, and liqueurs. Some of its stand-out brands include Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare, Southern Comfort, Fireball Cinnamon Whiskey, and Sazerac Rye.
Where can you buy Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace?
Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare bourbon can be bought at the distillery's onsite gift shop. Alternatively, you can purchase bottles from certain liquor stores and online retailers such as The Liquor Bros.
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day, both Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare offer incredible value, consistent quality, and the kind of craftsmanship you'd expect from one of the most respected distilleries in the world.
If you’re after a versatile, everyday sipper that holds up in cocktails and offers a smooth, sweet-spicy balance, Buffalo Trace is a fantastic choice. On the other hand, if you're looking for something a little more refined, you'll find that Eagle Rare is the better option.
Here at The Liquor Bros, we stock Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare, alongside an extensive range of other bourbons and spirits. Whether you're looking for an easy-sipping option or an exclusive bottle as a special gift, we have options for every bourbon lover.
